Salaamun alaykum, dear readers!

The traditional understanding of a messenger according to most Muslims is one who receives a new scripture, and the traditional understanding of a prophet is one who is sent to teach and judge by the scripture given to a messenger.

So according to the traditional school of thought, all messengers are prophets because they all have to teach and judge by their own scriptures, but not all prophets are messengers because some prophets are not given a new scripture to deliver.

  • Consequently, Muhammad is believed to be the final messenger because the Quran says he is the final prophet, and this definition of prophet does not allow a messenger who isn’t a prophet to exist.

But actually, the Quran says that prophet Muhammad is the final prophet, but not the final messenger.

The Quran says in verse 3:81 that there will be a messenger who comes after all prophets (including the final prophet) to confirm their scriptures. Moreover, it says that every prophet took a covenant from God to support and believe in this messenger when this messenger comes to them.

Verse 33:7 confirms that prophet Muhammad was one of the prophets who took this covenant with God. That means, just like the other prophets, he too agreed to believe in and support a messenger who will come after him.

Additionally, a messenger is someone who is sent by God to deliver any kind of message, or sent with some kind of mission from God. That message does not necessarily have to be a new scripture. The proof is that when God sent Moses and Aaron to Pharaoh, He did not give them a scripture to deliver to Pharaoh, yet God told Moses and Aaron to declare themselves as messengers. If the Sunni definition of messenger was correct, then Moses and Aaron would not be messengers until after they were given a scripture to deliver (which was when they left Egypt). But in the Quran, God states they were messengers before they were tasked with delivering any scripture.

  • Also, if the Sunni consensus is correct that Moses was both a prophet and a messenger, but Aaron was only a prophet and not a messenger, then why does the Quran say that God told Aaron to tell Pharaoh that he is a messenger?

But some might say, “Moses and Aaron are told to declare themselves as messengers to Pharaoh because they will, in the future, deliver scripture.”

  • But then, by this logic, Muhammad would have been a messenger of God since the day he was born, since adult Muhammad was destined to deliver the Quran in the future.
  • Rather, Moses and Aaron were messengers of God before they were tasked with the delivery of scripture because they were supposed to convey a message to Pharaoh (which is to request him to allow the Children of Israel to leave Egypt).

So when taking verses 3:81, 33:7, 20:46, 26:16 into account, let us review the Quranic definition of prophet and messenger:

  • If verse 3:81 says that God told every prophet that they were given a scripture, that means the definition of prophethood is being given a new scripture to deliver.
  • If a messenger is coming after all prophets according to verse 3:81, then the messenger is coming after all scriptures have been delivered. That means a messenger who doesn’t deliver a scripture is not a prophet. That is confirmed with verses 26:16 and 20:46, where Moses and Aaron were messengers before they were given a scripture to deliver.
  • So the definition of messenger is one who delivers any message, and the defintion of prophet is a specific kind of messenger who delivers a scripture. Thus, all prophets are messengers, but not all messengers are prophets.

Now someone might ask, “What about Aaron, the brother of Moses? He was a prophet, but he was not given a scripture, right?“

  • Yes, Moses was the one who directly received scripture after escaping Egypt with the Israelites, but the Quran defines the recipients as both Aaron and Moses, not Moses alone. That means the responsibility of delivery of the scripture was given to both equally, even though the direct revelation of the scripture was given to Moses alone.

Additionally, verse 3:81 says this future messenger will meet all the prophets. Of course, how can a future messenger meet prophet Muhammad and the other prophets when all the prophets are long dead?

  • Logically, this can only happen when God takes up the soul of this future messenger to somewhere in the afterlife to meet the prophets.
  • After this future messenger meets all the prophets, his soul must be sent back down to earth so that he can complete his mission that is stated in verse 3:81.

And if you are Muslim, then beware: verse 3:82 (which comes immediately after verse 3:81) says that whoever turns away after that (which means after the coming of the messenger mentioned in verse 3:81), then those are the transgressors (al-faasiqoon).

  • So if you (a Muslim) continue to insist that Muhammad is the final messenger, and disbelieve in the one who came after him after clear Quranic evidence has been presented to you, then you are a confirmed transgressor, and God Himself is the one calling you that. I’m sorry, brothers and sisters in Islam, but that is the harsh truth.

Identity of the Messenger of the Covenant

So who is the Messenger of the Covenant who was mentioned in verse 3:81?

The Quran tells the believers exactly how to identify this messenger.

The two arguments from the Quran that confirms this messenger’s identity involves the Quran’s 19-based mathematical composition, which you can read about here.

The Quran’s First Argument

In the Quran, specifically verses 74:30 and 74:31, God stated that there are 19 angels who guard over Hell.

The Quran then stated God assigned “their number” (the number of the angels, which is the number 19) to do five functions:

  1. Be a trial for the disbelievers,
  2. Produce certainty in the hearts of the People of the Book (Jews/Christians),
  3. Increase the faith of the believers,
  4. Remove the doubt from the believers and the People of the Book.
  5. Cause disbelievers to deny the number 19 by asking, “What did God really mean by this example?”

Here are the verses in full:

These verses are saying that the number 19 will one day prove the Quran as the truth, beyond all doubt, causing many Jews, Christians, and Muslims to achieve certainty (yaqeen), increase their faith (iman), and remove the doubts from their hearts. The number 19 will also serve as a test for the disbelievers.

The question now becomes: in what way will the number 19 prove to the world that Islam is the truth? How exactly will the number 19 will use to remove all doubt, increase faith and certainty of the believers, and test the disbelievers?

This information is part of the “ghayb (unseen/future in Arabic)” because only God knows the answer.

And the Quran states that God alone is the knower of the unseen, but if He wants to make some of the unseen known, He will only make it known to whichever messenger he wants, then it will be the job of the chosen messenger to spread this information to the world.

Take the prophecy of the smoke in Surah 44, for example. Nobody knows what will cause the smoke to happen on Earth, so this information is unseen (ghayb).

  • The same thing applies to the number 19, we all know the Prophecy of 19 exist, but the exact way that the Prophecy of 19 will be fulfilled is part of the unseen (ghayb).
  • And if God wanted this unseen information to be known to the people, He would only make it known to a chosen messenger according to verse 72:26-27. Then this messenger must convey that information to the public.

That means if any human being were to be the first person to know how the Prophecy of 19 will be fulfilled, that person must be a messenger of God.

  • The first knower of the Quran’s complex 19-based mathematical structure is Rashad Khalifa.
  • Therefore, Rashad Khalifa is a messenger of God.

Okay, we now know that Rashad is a messenger of God, but how do we know that he THE Messenger of the Covenant mentioned in verse 3:81?

  • A confirmed messenger of God would not lie about being the Messenger of the Covenant. So if Rashad insisted that he was the messenger of the covenant from verse 3:81, then that must be his identity.
  • Rashad did in fact state that God told him how he is the messenger who fulfills verse 3:81, so we know for sure that Rashad is the messenger after Muhammad who is mentioned in verse 3:81.

So even if you are already a hardcore Muslim and you don’t need to know about the Quran’s complex 19-based structure to increase your faith and certainty, it is still in your best interest to learn about it because Rashad’s identity as messenger (and whether you accept or reject him) depends solely on its existence.

The Quran’s Second Argument

The second argument is much more simple and straightforward than the first one.

The Quran in verse 3:81 stated that this messenger will, in the future, confirm the scriptures that were sent down to all prophets. If he will confirm all the scriptures, that means he will confirm the Quran as the truth one day.

The question is: how will he confirm the Quran in the future? That detail is relevant for guidance, because we need to know how he will do it if we want to recognize him.

  • The Quran guarantees it has every detail that is needed for guidance (verse 12:111, 7:52, and 16:89). That means somewhere in the Quran, there is a detail that shows how the messenger from verse 3:81 will confirm all the prophets a.

Verse 74:31 is the only verse in the Quran that talks about the Quran being confirmed in the future. It says the number 19 will someday confirm the Quran (and by proxy, all the scriptures before it) as the truth, beyond all doubts.

  • That means whoever confirmed the Quran with the number 19 (Rashad Khalifa) was a messenger.

And why doesn’t the Quran just directly say “a man named Rashad will be a messenger after Muhammad”? That’s because many Rashads after Muhammad would have falsely claimed messengership if God did that. So there was great wisdom in providing the identity of the Messenger of the Covenant via testable descriptions, rather than by name.

Who is Rashad Khalifa?

He was someone who trusted God so much that he disliked having insurance. And no, we at Masjid at-Tajdeed are not anti-insurance.

That is likely why in the middle of a speech (the 1989 conference speech) when certain audience members had to go to the airport, he offered his car keys and asked if anyone in the crowd will take his car and drive them to the airport.

The interesting thing about the Messenger of the Covenant is that he is not a Sunni, although he used to be a Sunni until the late 1970s.

He was the vice president of the Islamic Center of Tucson, but according to one of his closest companions, the Kurdish-American polymath Edip Yuksel, he started being increasingly more skeptical of Hadith since the late 1970s. He was finally kicked out of the Islamic Center when he rejected the punishment of stoning adulterers to death that is found in Hadith, saying that it contradicts the Quran.

  • After getting kicked out, Rashad established his own masjid in 1979, known as Masjid Tucson, which was dedicated to practicing Islam from the Quran alone.

Rashad said God informed him of his messengership during 1980, by which time he was no longer a Sunni.

Rashad’s Honesty

Being a messenger does not guarantee that someone will always be correct in their personal opinions.

This is why Rashad made the distinction between “Rashad the human” and “Rashad the messenger”. He stated that like everyone else, “Rashad the human” is required to follow and believe in “Rashad the messenger”. This is very important, because it clarifies that “Rashad the human” is like any other human, and is capable of making mistakes.

To give an example, one of Rashad Khalifa’s personal beliefs since at most 1985 is that Gog and Magog (Yajuj and Majuj in Arabic) will appear in 1700 AH.

Why does he believe this? He said that God and Magog appear in the Quran in verse 18:94, which is 17 verses before the end of Surah 18. Gog and Magog also appear in verse 21:96, which is also 17 verses before the end of Surah 21.

So he believed this is the Quran’s sign that Gog and Magog will appear in 17 centuries after the Quran’s revelation, or alternatively, in the year 1700 AH in the Islamic calendar.

And he could have easily said that this was information which God directly revealed to him through Gabriel, if he was dishonest. But he did not say that.

Here is what Rashad Khalifa said during a January 1990 Quranic study session, one of his last recorded study sessions before he was murdered later in January:

“From the revelation of the Quran to the appearance of Gog and Magog is 17 centuries. Edip brought up the valid possibility that it may be 17 days before the end of the world, or 17 hours, 17 something. Obviously, it’s not relevant to us. If it is relevant, God will let us know.“

So if Rashad was dishonest, he could have easily justified his personal belief by saying, “This is what God told me.” But he did the opposite, saying that God didn’t reveal anything about it.

Idolization of Rashad Khalifa Forbidden

Rashad Khalifa advised many times that obedience to the messenger is only obedience to his message, and not the messenger’s personal opinions or interpretations of the message. Rashad tells the people that while he is a messenger of God, it is their duty to disobey him if anything he says is not found in the Quran.

“We are not following Muhammad, we are not following Rashad Khalifa, we are not following any human being, and don’t let anybody tell you that. I don’t follow Rashad Khalifa, and you don’t follow Rashad Khalifa. We follow the words of God. We follow God, you and I.” 

“And if Rashad Khalifa says anything on his own, we don’t listen to him. We can listen and use our own discretion. But we do not follow what Rashad is saying, we follow what God is saying, you and I.” 

“You do not follow Rashad Khalifa. We do not follow Muhammad or Jesus. We do not follow any human being. We follow God, we know that.”

“And as you know, I’m the first one to tell you: if it is my opinion, if it is Rashad Khalifa, don’t follow him, because you’ll probably do the wrong thing. You must be sure you’re following God and following the word of God.”

“If I say anything that is not in the Quran, you tell me, ‘Get out of here.’” 

“The criteria of obeying the messenger is: whatever he is saying must be in the Quran, must be backed up by what God is saying. If it’s not in the Quran, it is your obligation to disobey.” 

“And we do not follow Rashad Khalifa or worship Rashad Khalifa, we follow what God says. If Rashad Khalifa says anything that is not in the Quran, you will be the first to tell him, ‘This is not in the Quran, why do you say that?’ And it is your duty not to obey him if it is not in the Quran.” 

“We are going out of our way to destroy idols, not to make the idols. Our only god is God. And we have reached the conviction in our hearts that God alone possesses all power. We reached the conviction in our hearts that no saint, no prophet, no Muhammad, no Jesus, no Rashad Khalifa, no anybody, no one other than God can guide us.” 

“We are people who know full well that no human being, certainly not Rashad Khalifa, can help you in anything except give you the message.” 

“And we’ll go to any extent to make sure that we are following God and the word of God, and not following the words of any human being.”

“But we make it very clear, we follow Maalik al-Mulk, the Possessor of All Kingship. We follow only God. We follow only the word of God.” 

Edip Yuksel has reposted email correspondence on his website, 19.org, showing that some followers of Rashad (while attacking Edip) have made claims that echo the Sunni-ism that Rashad was sent to denounce.

  • They have stated because Rashad is a messenger, he is the one whom God appointed to explain the Quran. Therefore, Rashad’s explanations and interpretations of the Quran cannot contain any error, even if they are not based on direct revelations given to him from Gabriel.
  • But logically, this is incorrect. Muslims are supposed to follow only the teachings that are directly revealed to the messenger (verse 7:203 and others). Nobody is responsible for adhering to the independent reasoning or personal understanding (ijtihad in Arabic) of any messenger, because that is elevating the messenger to the position of lawmaker.
  • While it was Rashad’s duty to teach and explain the Quran, being assigned a duty does not automatically mean that Rashad’s explanations will be error-free when he is carrying out this duty.
  • The Quran reveals several duties to all believers (such as invite others to God’s path), but that doesn’t automatically mean all believers will perfectly accomplish those duties without mistake. The same applies to the duty to teach the Quran that God revealed to the messenger; a messenger simply being assigned the duty to teach and explain the Quran does not by itself guarantee that the messenger won’t make any mistakes in his explanations when carrying out this duty.
  • Therefore, unless otherwise specified as revelation by Rashad, anything he taught is from his ijtihad, which is his independent reasoning and understanding of the Quran, and his independent reasoning is not free of mistakes. The ultimate proof is in Quranic study audio number 36, available on YouTube, where Rashad stated that he lets others correct his mistakes, and even deliberately lets himself make mistakes at times, because his mission is to destroy the idols and not make new ones.
  • Additionally, followers of Rashad must remember that Rashad was told by God that the Quran alone is the straight path. So anything that Rashad taught which cannot be found anywhere in the Quran is only Rashad’s independent reasoning. And every piece of information that Rashad ever stated was revealed to him was already mentioned somewhere in the Quran.

The Covenant Fulfilled

Rashad states that the covenant discussed in verse 3:81 was fulfilled on Dhul-Hijjah 3, 1391 A.H. Rashad mentioned in a 1988 speech that during this day, his soul was taken up by God to some unknown place to meet the prophets.

Rashad was told at the time that this event is currently not something he should be concerned about right now, but it is something that had to be done.

Then, he was shown a group of people and was informed that those were all the prophets God sent. They then came to him one by one and silently nodded their heads to show approval, then Rashad was sent back to Earth. Here is how he describes the event in Appendix 2 of his translation of the Quran:  

During my Hajj pilgrimage to Mecca, and before sunrise on Tuesday, Zul-Hijjah 3, 1391, December 21, 1971, I, Rashad Khalifa, the soul, the real person, not the body, was taken to some place in the universe where I was introduced to all the prophets as God’s Messenger of the Covenant. I was not informed of the details and true significance of this event until Ramadan 1408. What I witnessed, in sharp consciousness, was that I was sitting still, while the prophets, one by one, came towards me, looked at my face, then nodded their heads. God showed them to me as they had looked in this world, attired in their respective mode of dress. There was an atmosphere of great awe, joy, and respect. Except for Abraham, none of the prophets was identified to me. I knew that all the prophets were there, including Moses, Jesus, Muhammad, Aaron, David, Noah, and the rest. I believe that the reason for revealing Abraham’s identity was that I asked about him. I was taken aback by the strong resemblance he had with my own family – myself, my father, my uncles. It was the only time that I wondered, “Who is this prophet who looks like my relatives?” The answer came: “Abraham.” No language was spoken. All communication was done mentally. 

That incident, which took place during my pilgrimage to Mecca, was the fulfillment of Verse 3:81. That incident took place while I was fully awake, and I have shared the details with my family, my family of believers, and with my friends. 

It is worth clarifying that there is a slight inconsistency with the date. Dhul-Hijjah 3, 1391 in Mecca is actually Wednesday, January 19, 1972. But Rashad remembers that day in Mecca as a Tuesday as per his 1988 Conference speech, given that his favorite Quran reciter at the time (Mahmoud al-Banna) used to recite the Quran live on radio at Tuesday mornings, and given that he says this happened while he was listening to al-Banna in the morning with his brother.

In the 1988 Conference speech, he recalled going to Hajj with his family. He brought 100 cassette tapes with him to Hajj, and told his brother Atef (who eventually came to believe Rashad’s messengership) on that Tuesday to record al-Banna’s recitals with these cassette tapes.

Thus, it is likely the actual date in Hijri calendar is Dhul-Hijjah 2, 1391, or Tuesday January 18, 1972.

Additionally, an Iranian newspaper published a picture featuring Rashad Khalifa and his mother in front of the Kaaba at the Hajj during January 1973. Here is the picture:

Someone who knows Farsi can probably understand what this 1973 newspaper article is talking about, but the picture caption that I circled in red translates to, “Dr. Rashad Khalifa and his mother at the pilgrimage to the House of God.“

Thus, it is confirmed that Rashad indeed went Hajj with his family in the early 1970s, like he mentioned. So there are two options: either Rashad met the prophets in January 1973, or he did so in January 1972, or he did in some other Hajj date in the early 1970s, But Rashad is definitely misremembering the time when he met the prophets.

  • Rashad has previously admitted he is often not good at remembering dates. In a 1989 Friday Khutbah, he admitted that he only recently found out he unveiled the Quran’s 19-based structure in 1974. He said that his son repeatedly insisted Rashad discovered the Quran’s 19-based structure in 1974, but Rashad didn’t believe him and thought his son was maybe a few years off the mark. When Rashad went through his old records, he found that his son was indeed right, that Rashad first unveiled his discovery in January of 1974.

The meeting with the prophets that Rashad experienced marked the start of Rashad’s messengership, because the covenant in 3:81 says that a messenger will come to all past prophets as one who will confirm all previous scriptures. If Rashad came to them in 1972, then that was the day Rashad officially became a messenger, although he not told by God of his messengership at the time why this event took place. He was not yet aware of the 19-based mathematical composition of the Quran in 1972, nor was Rashad made aware that he was a messenger until 1980.

In fact, it was in 1968 that he first started to study the Quranic Initials, and he states in his newsletter that at the time that while the number 19 was frequently noticed during his study of Quranic initials, his main finding at the time regarding the Quranic initials (which he published in his 1973 book Miracle of the Quran: Significance of the Mysterious Alphabets) was that the letters of each initial occurred in the highest proportions in the Surahs that they occurred compared to other Surahs. Out of the 114 Surahs, there are only 29 of them with Quranic initials which nobody understood the purpose or significance of. Surah 50 is one of them, and it is initialed with the letter “Qaaf”. Rashad found that Surah 50 has the highest proportion of the letter Qaaf relative to other letters than does the other Surahs of the Quran, meaning it has the highest percentage of the occurrence of the letter Qaaf in its verses out of all Surahs, and it’s the same for every initial except Surah 36 (initialed with the letters “Ya” and “Seen”), which contained the lowest proportion of those two letters out of all Surahs.

It wasn’t until after he published the book in 1973 that he realized that maybe there’s something else that needs further research. He noticed a recurring pattern of 19 at the time when analyzing the Quran but didn’t think much of it when writing the book.

But as he re-examined the data after publishing that book in 1973, he realized that the letters of the Quranic initials seemed to occur in the initialed Surahs in multiples of 19, and then finally in January of 1974, the fact that a vast and complex 19-based mathematical system pervades the entire Quran became a reality to him.

So, January of 1974 should be one of the most significant dates in Islamic history to have occurred, because that is when the Messenger of the Covenant in verse 3:81 fulfilled the prophecy in verse 74:31.  

Rashad also stated that even during the year 1980, while he was told that he was a messenger of God, he wasn’t told that he was the Messenger of the Covenant mentioned in verse 3:81. The explanation of verse 3:81 didn’t come to him until God told him in 1988, according to Rashad.

He stated, in his speech at a 1989 conference, that in 1980 he was approached by the angel Gabriel who informed him that he was a messenger. But Rashad thought it was Iblis, the devil/satan, and invoked God’s protection and refuge against the devil.

But after some back and forth discussion, Gabriel assured him that he was not Satan, and conveyed that Rashad was God’s messenger and that verse 3 of Surah Ya Seen is addressed directly to Rashad.

Afterward, Rashad resolved to just teach God’s message (the Quran), believing that there was no need to make the announcement, and fearing the ridicule and backlash he would receive even from his own friends and family whom he loved very much and wanted to be with in the Hereafter. He said, “I went on my merry way, saying I will preach the word of God alone.”

So he never made a public announcement, and he even ignored repeated messages from God (through Gabriel) which encouraged him to announce his messengership. But 8 years later (April 1988), he was told by God that he was going to Hell and that someone else will be substituted in his place for the job. After sincere repentance, God accepted it and restored his position.

After that, Rashad announced his messengership during a Friday khutbah which was recorded on video on April 15, 1988, and the announcement is publicly available on YouTube.

He says in the October 1989 edition of his newsletter Muslim Perspective:  

For eight years, I had maintained the same views as those who believe that an announcement was not necessary. I used to think: Why is the announcement necessary? Why not preach the word of God, uphold the word of God ALONE, and preach the worship of God ALONE, without announcing anything about the messengership? In those days of ignorance, I resisted making such an announcement. Finally, I was told that I was too coward to carry out the duties of God’s messenger. I was fired. It took a whole night of repenting, crying, apologizing, and pledging. When I reached a solid conviction that I must make the announcement, even at the cost of losing my own children and my best friends, I was restored. The following night, I spoke with my daughter during the pre-dawn meal of a Ramadan night, and I was trying to be as diplomatic as I could be. My daughter interrupted, “What are you trying to say, Dad? I knew all along that you are God’s messenger.” I received the same response from all the believers around me. They had known me for a long time, and they knew that I was not a crazy man. They realized that a person who lies about God or claims messengership falsely has to be a person who does not believe in God or the Hereafter; a person who does not expect to stand before God on the Day of Judgment to answer for his actions. 

He stated that God accepted the repentance for his past 8 years of cowardice and restored his mission. He says in his May 1988 newsletter: 

The recent announcement that I am God’s commissioned messenger to the world was NOT my idea. In fact, God Most Gracious has been immensely merciful towards me. Despite my cowardice for eight long years, God has accepted my repentance and my solemn pledge to (1) announce my identity as God’s messenger, and (2) never hesitate, hold back, or waver in declaring such identity. Thus, I can no longer afford to hesitate or be humble about this divine truth.

Rashad stated in a September 1988 conference speech that God told him about the covenant in verse 3:81, and how his meeting with the prophets that occurred many years ago was the fulfillment of that covenant.

The explanation he received from God in April 1988 was that when Rashad was taken by God to meet the prophets, God informed the prophets (who were in the afterlife) that the person standing before them is the one whom they all took a pledge to support before the creation, who will confirm all the scriptures they were given, and asked them if they agree to fulfill that pledge.

Thus, when they all came to him one by one, nodding their heads, they were in fact expressing their support of Rashad in response to God’s question.

Fear of the Public

In fact, Rashad (during a 1989 conference speech, and I believe one of his Friday sermons too) has recounted the story about one example of his cowardice that occurred during a 1986 speech.

He said that he has long prayed that someone would not directly ask him, point-blank, if he were a messenger, because he would have admitted it and his secret would have gotten out. In the few occasions that someone asked him if he were a prophet, he would say no and respond that Muhammad was the last prophet. But no one asked him before if he was a messenger, and he wanted it to stay that way. He used to pray that no one asked him that question.

So after some heated back-and-forth discussion between Rashad Khalifa who was on the podium, and audience member Soussan Rey, she “let the cat out of the bag” and came to the conclusion that Rashad was a messenger of God.

Rashad suddenly went quiet after that, at a loss for how to answer. He said that Kathryn Kolton later told him that she noticed how quiet he was when Soussan asked him that. He said that what the audience didn’t know at the time was that he was praying very hard that no one would come to him afterward and ask him point-blank, to his face, because he would have said yes if that happened. Rashad’s lack of response caught the attention of many. Very likely, he just sidestepped the question and redirected the attention to something else.

Rashad recalls Kathryn telling him that at the time, she overheard an audience member Ismail Barakat talking angrily amongst a couple people, saying he was determined to go ask Rashad after this event point-blank if he was a messenger. But he did not do so. So at some point during a speech, Rashad invited Ismail to the podium to explain why.

Ismail Barakat explained that the Quran-alone movement was supposed to be about destroying idols, not making new ones. Ismail recalled that in his understanding at the time, a messenger was someone who delivered a scripture. Rashad didn’t deliver any scripture to his knowledge, and if Rashad said he did, then he would be a confirmed liar. So he was very determined to confront Rashad point-blank and get a straight answer out of him.

But Ismail said, while swearing by God as his witness, that when he confronted Rashad point blank, he was unable to open his mouth to ask Rashad that question. Rashad believes this was God answering his prayers at the time.

This shows that Rashad being a messenger was not just some made-up story that he came up with in 1988 to gain status; he had known it for much longer than that, but he was hiding it out of fear of the public.

Why Send a New Messenger If the Quran Is Complete?

Some people may question why God would want to send a new messenger if the Quran is already complete.

  • The first reason is because as you have already seen, certain prophecies in the Quran required a messenger after Muhammad to fulfill them.
  • The second reason is that if most Muslims are practicing and teaching Islam the wrong way, then it makes absolute sense for God to send a new messenger as a mercy to the people, to remind the people (especially the Muslims) that the straight path is following the Quran alone, instead of following both Quran and Hadith.

Rashad’s Messengership Confirms Two False Verses

It is known that the Quran’s 19-based mathematical structure collapses when verses 9:128-129 are included. You can see the evidence by clicking this link. I have documented more than 170 mathematical violations of the Quran’s 19-based structure in this website that occur when those two verses are included in the Quran.

Due primarily to the mathematical evidence, as well as evidence from multiple Hadith reports (which you can read about in this link), Rashad declared in 1985 that these two verses are false, man-made additions that were not present in the original Quran.

  • As a result of this declaration, Rashad received intense criticism, and many Muslims cite this as a reason for rejecting Rashad’s messengership.

But according to the Quran, if Rashad is a true messenger from God (which has already been proven earlier in this article), then verses 9:128-129 must be false verses. Here is why:

  • The role of the Messenger of the Covenant according to verse 3:81 is to confirm all scriptures, including the Quran given to Muhammad, as the truth. That means Rashad is supposed to confirm the whole Quran as the truth, not part of the Quran.
  • If Rashad (as Messenger of the Covenant) was supposed to confirm the whole Quran as the truth from God rather than part of the Quran, and if the only Quran that Rashad recited from and confirmed was the standard 1924 Cairo edition (excluding verses 9:128-129), then verses 9:128-129 do not belong in the Quran. Otherwise, Rashad failed to complete the job the Quran assigned him.
  • The prophet Muhammad was told by God to say in verse 10:15 that he is not able to change the Quran without permission. This rule therefore applies to the messenger that came after Muhammad (Rashad). God would not allow any real messenger, including Rashad, to remove verses 9:128-129 from the Quran if they were real verses.
  • So if Rashad was a real messenger, and if Rashad removed verses 9:128-129 from the Quran, then it logically follows that verses 9:128-129 are false verses.

Additionally, verse 98:2-3 mentions a messenger sent to the People of the Book and the polytheists who recited to them purified pages of Quranic text that contained correct writings.

  • Two messengers fit the description of this verse: Muhammad, and Rashad.
  • Both were sent to the People of the Book and the polytheists, and both were reciting purified pages of a written Quran, so this statement applies equally to both of them.
  • If the written Quran that Rashad recited from were purified pages, but those purified pages did not contain verse 9:128-129, then that means these two verses do not belong in the Quran.

The same applies to when Rashad corrected the spelling of the initial “Noon” in Surah 68. The initial is still the letter “Noon” but is spelled out as “Noon waw noon” instead of written as a single, standalone letter.

  • It’s like spelling the letter D as “D e e” instead of “D”.
  • Visit this page for further details and explanation.

The other correction that Rashad made to our Quran manuscripts was writing the “bastatan” in verse 7:69 as “ba seen ta” instead of “ba saad ta” as it was erroneously written in the 1924 Cairo Quran.

  • I highly encourage you to visit this page for further explanation and details.

Rashad’s Message

So, what is the message that the Messenger of the Covenant was sent with?

1. Confirming the Quran With Number 19

His first and primary mission given by God was to confirm the Quran and all previous scriptures of God as the truth from God, as stated in verse 3:81.

But how is he supposed to confirm the Quran and all previous scriptures? The Quran clarifies in verse 74:30-31 that the number 19 will cause Jews, Christians, and Muslims to increase their faith and their certainty, and remove the doubts from their hearts.

Such increase in faith and certainty, and the removal of doubt, can only happen if the number 19 confirmed and proved that the Quran is the truth from God.

  • If the number 19 confirmed the Quran, then the number 19 also confirmed all other scriptures which came before the Quran (Gospel, Torah, the scriptures given to Abraham and David, and others).

Thus, Rashad’s main duty, as given by God in the Quran, is to confirm the Quran as the truth from God by using the number 19.

  • The way Rashad fulfilled this duty is by teaching the Quran’s 19-based mathematical system.

2. Confirm That the Quran Alone Is the Straight Path

Another duty given to Rashad in the Quran in verse 3:81 to practice and preach following the Quran alone. Verse 3:81 says that the messenger of the covenant will come after all the prophets are given their scriptures, which means this messenger will be sent under the law of the scripture given to the final prophet (Muhammad).

  • The law of Muhammad is the Quran alone. Hence, according to verse 3:81, God will send the Messenger of the Covenant to follow, teach, and invite to the Quran alone.

This was fulfilled in 1980, sometime after his 45th birthday, Rashad was approached by the angel Gabriel, who told him, “You are one of the messengers. Surah Ya Seen, 3, applies to you.“

Now, if anybody is familiar with Surah Ya Seen, they would know that verse 4 is a continuation of verse 3. The two verses, when combined, says:

In short, God told Rashad through Gabriel that he is a messenger who is on the straight path.

  • That means the path that Rashad was following at the time (following the Quran alone, and rejecting Hadith as a source of Islamic law) is the straight path.

3. Convey the Time of the End of the World

Another of Rashad’s responsibilities as messenger that was mentioned in the Quran is to convey the time that the world will end.

To keep it very brief, the Quran said in verse 20:15 that God “almost hides” the Hour.

  • The “Hour” is an event, and all events consist of three things: time, place, and action. We all know the action (destruction of the universe) and the place (the universe). But the only unknown part of the Hour is the time.
  • So according to verse 20:15, the timing of the Hour is not fully hidden, but is almost hidden.
  • Think of it like this: let’s say that someone has a hemoglobin A1c level of 5.6%, and the threshold for prediabetes is an A1c level of 5.7%. Does that person have prediabetes or not? The answer is no, he is not a prediabetic, but he is almost a prediabetic.
  • Because God made the Hour almost hidden, rather than fully hidden, that means God intends for the people to learn about its time, and the information was placed somewhere for us to find it in the future. Otherwise, the Hour would have remained fully hidden.

Alright, but where did God put the timing of the end of the world, if it is not hidden? Verse 43:61 says the Quran contains the knowledge of the Hour. So the time when the Hour will take place is inside the Quran somewhere.

Also, verse 72:26-27 says that God will only make known any part of the unseen that He wants through a chosen messenger.

  • Verse 7:187 and other verses say that prophet Muhammad does not have access to the time when the world will end (which is “unseen” information).
  • So if God intends to make known the time the world will end through a messenger, but that messenger is not prophet Muhammad, then it will be made known from the Quran through a specific messenger after Muhammad.
  • And it was Rashad who found the time of the Hour from the Quran, so he was the messenger chosen by God to fulfill this mission.
  • Rashad found out in the year 1980 from the Quran that the world will end in the year 2280 CE. I provide an in-depth explanation from multiple Quranic verses about why this is the correct time for the end of the world in this link.

Some might say, “But doesn’t the Quran tell the prophet to say the knowledge of the Hour is only with God?”

  • Yes, but just because the knowledge of something is only with God, does not mean the knowledge will stay only with God forever. For any unseen information (such as the time the world will end), the knowledge is with God alone, unless He chooses to make this information known to the people.

Some might respond: “Doesn’t the Quran say the Hour will come suddenly? How can we know the time in advance if it comes suddenly?“

  • The answer is yes, the Hour will come suddenly…for the disbelievers. Not once does the Quran say that the Hour will come suddenly for the believers. That is because the believers will know exactly when it will occur.

Here is a list of every single verse in the Quran where the word “baghtah” (suddenly) appears in connection with the Hour. These verses indicate that the Hour will not come suddenly for believers, but it will come suddenly for the disbelievers and the wrongdoers:

Some might ask, “Why does the timing of the end of the world matter? Why should I care?”

  • Personally, it does not matter to me much when God wants to end the world. It’s His creation, so He alone has the right to choose the end date.
  • My concern is that people continue to attack and criticize Rashad as a false messenger because he said the world will end in 2280 CE. So it’s important to set the record straight and show how the Quran completely supports what Rashad is saying.

4. Other Revelations

Additionally, Rashad himself said that all information he receives and passes on to the people from God is already found in the Quran (Muslim Perspective, February 1990). Here are some additional messages that God communicated to Rashad through the angel Gabriel.

  • The explanation of verse 3:81 that Rashad received in 1988 after he was restored to his position as messenger, that not only was he a messenger, but he is the Messenger of the Covenant mentioned in this verse. God explained to Rashad that his meeting with the prophets in Heaven many years before was the fulfillment of the covenant in verse 3:81.
  • The proclamation that all who die before age 40 will go to Heaven (the Quranic evidence of this, verse 46:15, is discussed here). Rashad said in Appendix 32 and in a Quranic study session that he was tasked by God to deliver this piece of information.
  • The message that after Rashad dies, millions of believers will know that he is the Messenger of the Covenant, who represents the Messiah the Jews are waiting for, the second coming of Christ that the Christians anticipate, and the Mahdi that Muslims anticipate. This does not mean he is all three of these people. Rather, it means he is neither the Mahdi, nor the Christ, nor the Messiah, but was sent by God in their place. This is evident from the complete and fully detailed Quran, which does not mention the second coming of Jesus or a future Messiah, but mentions the coming of Rashad in verse 3:81.
  • Rashad received a message from God, who stated that like the time of Noah, those who refuse to stand with God’s Messenger of the Covenant will be destroyed. 
  • A “new proclamation” from God that Rashad received, instructing people of all religions to “Purify, unify, and consolidate your religions into one,” by forgetting all idols and devoting themselves totally to God alone. This will be the bare minimum needed to attain salvation. This message is discussed in depth here.

5. Quranic Verses Referring to Rashad

Let’s say that someone asks, “What Quranic verses are directly addressing Rashad, or talking about Rashad Khalifa, apart from verse 3:81?”

  • The Quran is valid for all times. Therefore, any verse that is traditionally believed to be talking to or about Muhammad, but is general enough to be talking to or about Rashad due to him being a messenger too, can and should be interpreted as such.

From time to time, God used a small subset of verses (out of all verses that are applicable to Rashad) to communicate with Rashad, by saying something like, “Verse so-and-so refers to you,” and “This verse refers to you.”

You have already learned about verse 36:3. The very first message that was sent to Rashad through Gabriel was that he was one of the messengers and that verse 36:3 referred to him.

  • Besides that, the other verses that Rashad said that God said they refer to him are: Verses 98:2, 81:19-24, 72:1-28, 61:9, 48:28, 46:35, 44:13, 43:43, 42:24, 41:43, 35:24, 34:28, 34:43, 34:46, 28:44, 26:214-223, 25:27-30, 25:56, 24:62, 22:49, 13:37-38, 13:30, 9:33, 5:19, 3:81, 2:252, 2:119, and 2:23-24.
  • Those are not the ONLY verses that are addressing Rashad of course. Verse 38:65, is not one of the listed verses, but it tells the messenger to say, “I am only a warner.” Since Muhammad is a messenger and a warner, this verse applies to him. But since Rashad is also a messenger and a warner, this verse applies to Rashad too.
  • But the listed verses just the ones that Rashad said God specifically pointed out to him. This is just how God used verses of the Quran itself to communicate to Rashad.

During a Quranic study, when discussing Surah 72 and what Rashad learned from God, he stated that God inspired to him that a group of formerly Christian jinns walked by his masjid (Masjid Tucson) and heard the Quran there. After learning about how amazing the Quran is and its miracle, they became believers.

Here is what Rashad said, when discussing Surah 72 during a Quranic study session, after discussing how the Surah is addressed to Rashad himself: 

  • “This is not my personal opinion. If this was my personal opinion, I’d be wrong. This is not my personal opinion.” 
  • “And when I tell you this, either I’m a very, very bad person, or I’m really a messenger of God. Because nobody will fabricate lies against God and attribute it to God in this flagrant manner, unless he’s really, really a disbeliever who doesn’t think he will face God one day on the Day of Judgement. So take your pick, there are only two extremes here: either a very bad person who claims to be receiving information from God, or a true messenger of God.” 

Anything else beyond this is Rashad’s own statement and opinion, not revelation from God. Because he is human and not perfect, any statement that Rashad made beyond revelation must be verified by comparing it with what the Quran says.

Conclusion: The Killing of Rashad

The Islamic Fiqh Council is the organization of the Muslim World League that specializes in Islamic law.

The Islamic Fiqh Council held their 11th conference in Mecca on February 1989. The chairman of that conference was Abdul-Aziz ibn Baz, who would become Saudi Arabia’s Grand Mufti 4 years later. The organization issued a fatwa (religious ruling) labelling Rashad Khalifa as “apostate” and “criminal”. And Rashad was also falsely accused in this fatwa of claiming to be a prophet (which Rashad has strongly denied, multiple times).

  • You can view the entire fatwa by clicking this link.

In Sunni Islam, apostasy (a Muslim becoming a non-Muslim) is punishable by death because it is one of the three valid reasons to take the life of a Muslim. Thus, by falsely labelling Rashad an apostate, the IFC may have inspired Sunni terrorists to take action and murder Rashad.

The Muslim World League and the IFC used to be just a propaganda organization for spreading Wahhabi Islam before becoming moderate. Wahhabis strongly believe in the death penalty for apostasy. In fact, apostasy is punishable by execution in Saudi Arabia because of Wahhabi influence.

  • So when the Wahhabi scholars who wrote this fatwa declared Rashad as an apostate, this meant that they wanted him dead. Very likely, the Saudi Arabian authorities would have arrested Rashad and executed him if he had went there for Hajj in 1989.

Since this fatwa, the death threats against Rashad intensified, both verbal and written. Investigators in 1989 (after the IFC’s fatwa) uncovered a four-page murder plan found in a storage locker to assassinate Rashad Khalifa, written by members of the terrorist group Jamaat ul-Fuqra.

The plan was to stab Rashad to death inside the masjid kitchen at night, and it said that the knife was chosen because it was the quietest possible murder method. Shooting Rashad was discussed as an alternative. There were also pictures of surveillance footage of the inside and outside of the masjid found in the locker along with the murder plan.

Rashad Khalifa was ultimately beaten and stabbed to death 29 times inside Masjid Tucson’s kitchen before sunrise on January 31st, 1990, by a Jamaat ul-Fuqra affiliate.

The assassination was done in a manner that is consistent with the written plan. The murder was “a carbon copy of the handwritten plan,” according to Colorado’s former assistant attorney general Doug Wamsley. 

The image below shows Glen Francis, the Jamaat ul-Fuqra affiliate who assassinated Rashad Khalifa in 1990, and was subsequently arrested in 2009 after evading the police for 19 years:

Several other members of Jamaat ul-Fuqra, such as James Williams (who was the leader of al-Fuqra’s local branch in Denver, Colorado) were arrested for being involved in the 1989 conspiracy to murder Rashad.

So while justice has been served, the most important thing that all Muslims should do now is to accept Rashad as messenger and follow the message he was sent with: the Quran alone.

Additional Resources

Rashad Khalifa’s newsletters and his translation of the Quran (plus Appendices) can be found on the website of the masjid he founded:

This is a YouTube playlist of Rashad’s recorded group Quranic study sessions: (56) 01 Quran Study From Azhar 1 Sura 72;19 28 & Sura 73 By Kathryn Jinns 05 26 1989 – YouTube

And here is a recommended YouTube playlist of various recorded speeches and Friday sermons from Rashad Khalifa: 01 What Life is All About & Who is GOD?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *